Skip to main content

Butt Plugs

Butt plugs are built to stay in place rather than move, and every one here has a flared base. No exceptions. You will find silicone, glass and steel, beginner sizes through advanced, plus vibrating, tail and jeweled styles.

Skip to pagination
Iridescent pouch labeled Butt Stuff with a black silicone heart-handle anal plug, rose-gold heart-jewel plug, and lube.Close-up of iridescent holographic drawstring pouch with Butt Stuff text on the front.

Butt Stuff 3 Piece Gift Set

50.00 USD
Two metallic teal aluminum plugs: small with fluffy blue pom-pom bunny tail, medium with faceted aquamarine jewel base.Metallic teal blue bunny-tail and jewel-base aluminum butt plug set, showing both plugs side by side on a white background.

Blue Metallic Bunny Tail Butt Plug Set

30.00 USD
Rainbow chrome small butt plug with a tapered shaft and a flared round base set with a faceted rainbow gem. NS Novelties.Alternate view of the rainbow small butt plug showing the round rainbow gem in the flared base.

Rear Assets Technocolored Small Rainbow

12.00 USD
Booty Sparks Light Up Small Anal Plug in polished silver aluminum alloy with a round flared base and a lit rainbow LED disk.Light Up Small Anal Plug shown from the side showing the tapered tip, narrow neck, and round flared LED base.

Light Up Small Anal Plug

33.00 USD
Out of stock

The 9's First Glass Teddy Love Butt Plug - Pink

11.00 USD
Rainbow chrome small butt plug with a tapered shaft and a flared heart base set with a rainbow heart gem. NS Novelties.Alternate view of the rainbow small butt plug showing the rainbow heart gem in the flared heart base.

Rear Assets Technocolored Heart Rainbow Butt Plug

14.00 USD
Pink metallic aluminum butt plug set: small plug with pink pom-pom tail next to medium plug with pink jewel inlay base.NIXIE pink metallic butt plug set with original box, showing the pom-pom plug and jewel plug in two graduated sizes.

Pink Metallic Bunny Tail Butt Plug Set

30.00 USD
Rose gold aluminum butt plug with a tapered shaft and a flared base topped with a pink resin rose. NS Novelties.Rose gold floral butt plug on its side next to a standing plug, both showing the pink rose base.

Rear Assets Rose Gold Floral Butt Plug

15.00 USD
Rose gold chrome aluminum butt plug with a tapered shaft and a flared heart base set with a faceted pink gem.Alternate view: Rose gold chrome aluminum butt plug with a tapered shaft and a flared heart base set with a faceted pink gem.

Rear Assets Pink Heart Rose Gold Medium Butt Plug

14.00 USD
Teal silicone anal plug with tapered tip, beaded ring at the neck, and a flared T-bar base with b-Vibe lettering.Second view of the B-Vibe Rimming Plug in teal silicone with beaded rim ring.

B-Vibe Rimming Plug in Teal

165.00 USD
Rose gold aluminum small butt plug with a tapered shaft and a flared round base set with a faceted pink gem. NS Novelties.Alternate view of the rose gold small butt plug showing the round pink gem base. NS Novelties.

Rear Assets Rose Gold Small Pink

13.00 USD
Iridescent blue silicone prostate plug with a curved base, finger-ring loop, and a black bullet, on white background.Size diagram of the prostate plug: 4.25 inch length, 3.25 inch insertable, 1.25 inch width, on white.

Matrix Teleportation Plug Lunar Blue

69.00 USD
Front view of twisted butt plug in purple-pink-blue gradient silicone with swirl ridges and flared baseSide view of purple-pink-blue swirl butt plug on pink clouds background with measurement annotations showing dimensions

Creature Cocks Unicorn Swirl Silicone Butt Plug Large

26.00 USD
Polished blue metal teardrop butt plug attached to a long fluffy blue and white ombre faux fur tail, on a white background.Additional view, product photo on white background.

Blue Ombre Tail Butt Plug

30.00 USD
Small clear borosilicate glass anal plug with tapered teardrop body and faceted red heart gem set in the flared base.Side view of small clear glass anal plug with red heart gem base showing tapered teardrop body and narrow neck.

Small Glass Red Heart Gem Butt Plug

16.00 USD
Small clear glass butt plug with a tapered shaft and a flared round base set with a faceted pink gem.Top down view of the small glass butt plug showing the round flared base and the pink gem in the center.

Small Glass Pink Gem Butt Plug

16.00 USD
Doobie 420 anal set, three dark green silicone plugs, small smooth, medium ribbed, large tapered, pot-leaf flared bases.Side view of the Doobie 420 set showing the three sizes lined up on pot-leaf bases.

Doobie 420 Butt Plugs Set

44.00 USD
Rose gold aluminum medium butt plug with a tapered shaft and a flared round base set with a faceted pink gem. NS Novelties.Alternate view of the rose gold medium butt plug showing the round pink gem base. NS Novelties.

Rear Assets Rose Gold Medium Pink

17.00 USD
Polished silver aluminum anal plug with a tapered shaft and a flared base set with a faceted red heart gem. Booty Sparks.

Red Heart Gem Anal Plug - Medium

23.00 USD
Three matte black silicone anal plugs with red faceted heart gem bases, beside the Bling Plugs Trainer Kit package.

Bling Red Heart Shaped Training Kit

55.00 USD
1 of 4

Recently viewed

What is a butt plug?

A butt plug is a toy designed to stay in place rather than move. That is the whole difference between a plug and every other anal toy. It goes in, it stays, and the sensation is fullness and pressure rather than thrusting.

People use them for a few different reasons. Some wear one during other kinds of sex because it makes everything else feel more intense. Some use them to get comfortable with anal play at their own pace. Some just like the feeling of being full. The anus has a dense band of nerve endings at the opening, and for people with a prostate, a plug can put steady pressure on it without any effort.

The one rule that is not negotiable: a butt plug must have a flared base or a retrieval ring. Unlike a vagina, the rectum has no natural stopping point, and anything without a base can travel. Every plug on this page has one. If you are ever shopping elsewhere and a toy does not, put it down.

Types of butt plugs

Plugs vary more than people expect. The main styles:

  • Beginner plugs: narrow, short, usually soft silicone. Smaller than you would guess from photos, which is the point.
  • Vibrating plugs: add buzz to the pressure. Some are remote or app-controlled, which makes them workable for partner play or wearing out.
  • Tail plugs: a plug with a tail attached. Bunny, fox, pony and unicorn. Pet play, costume, or just because they look good.
  • Jeweled and gem plugs: a stone or crystal set into the base. Usually metal or glass, usually weighted, and the most popular style for anyone who wants the plug to be visible.
  • Glass and steel: firm, heavy, and they hold temperature. Run one under warm or cool water first and the sensation changes completely. Also the easiest material to clean.
  • Rimming and rotating plugs: beads or rings inside the shaft that move. The most sensation-heavy option and not where anyone should start.
  • Prostate plugs: curved to press forward against the prostate rather than sitting straight.

Adjacent to all of it: anal beads if you want movement instead of stillness, and anal lube, which is not optional here. The full anal toys range has everything together.

How to choose the right one

Start smaller than your ego wants you to. This is the single most common mistake in the category. A plug that is too big is not a challenge, it is a bad evening. Insertable width matters far more than length, and the widest point is what your body actually has to accommodate.

Check the base before anything else. Flared, wide, or a retrieval ring. A base narrower than the widest part of the plug is not a base. Everything on this page passes, but it is the first thing to look at anywhere else.

Material changes the experience more than shape does. Silicone has give, which forgives a lot, and it is the right beginner choice. Glass and steel have none, so they feel bigger at the same measurement, but they are non-porous, easy to sterilize and hold temperature. Nothing porous, ever, in this category.

Use more lube than you think, and the right kind. Anal tissue does not self-lubricate. Thicker, longer-lasting formulas exist for exactly this. Silicone lube lasts longest but degrades silicone toys, so pair it with glass or steel and use water-based with silicone.

Skip anything with a numbing agent. Pain is the signal your body uses to tell you to stop. Numbing it does not make you ready, it makes you unable to tell when something is wrong.